Audit it yourself
Sources & the claims ledger
Everything in the investigation resolves to a source on the public record. Every source carries a live link and a Wayback-archived copy, so the proof survives a dead link or a pulled page. Every claim is scored, in the open. Nothing here asks for your trust. It asks you to check.
The claims ledger
Every claim, scored
- Locked The scale
The Irving group is not one company but somewhere between 200 and 300 privately held companies; because they are private, no outsider knows the exact number.
- Locked The scale
After a long restructuring completed around 2012, the empire split into three pillars: J.D. Irving Ltd., Irving Oil, and Ocean Capital.
- Locked The scale
The family’s companies produce roughly two-thirds of New Brunswick’s exports and have long been estimated to employ about one in twelve of the province’s workers.
- Locked The machine that hides the machine
Every Irving company is privately held and discloses nothing to the public, so the true size of the fortune cannot be totalled by anyone outside the family.
- Locked The machine that hides the machine
Much of the fortune was routed through tax-free trusts in Bermuda set up by K.C. Irving, and the family rushed to unwind them before a 2013 Canadian law would have taxed income from offshore trusts benefiting Canadian residents.
- Locked We are paying them
UNB Saint John economist Rob Moir argued New Brunswickers pay taxes that are then transferred to one of the richest corporations in Canada through subsidies.
- Locked We are paying them
The total public subsidy to the Irving companies is unknowable by design, because private companies need not disclose grants, tax breaks, or loan guarantees; it was partly exposed only by a U.S. Department of Commerce subsidy probe.
- Locked The power bill nobody voted for
Since 2012 the province has required NB Power to buy electricity from six mills (three owned by J.D. Irving) at a high price and sell it back low, a paper transaction in which no electricity changes hands, run until NB Power loses a set subsidy amount.
- Locked The power bill nobody voted for
In 2025 the subsidy was forced up about 35 percent to a record $16.6 million; every NB electricity customer pays for it, roughly $20 a year on the average household bill.
- Locked The power bill nobody voted for
Green leader David Coon argues the government, not NB Power ratepayers, should fund any mill subsidy, because "NB Power’s money doesn’t come out of thin air, it comes out of what people pay on their power bills."
- Locked The power bill nobody voted for
NB Power is a provincial Crown corporation and Saint John Energy is owned by the City of Saint John; neither is owned by the Irvings. The issue is a mandated public subsidy, not secret ownership.
Caveat This corrects a common false claim. Stating the subsidy accurately is what makes it impossible to wave away; the ownership rumour would be neither true nor defensible.
- Locked The Canaport tax break
A 1981 provincial property-tax exemption on the Canaport crude terminal was never removed, saving Irving an estimated $20M+ in provincial property taxes.
- Locked The Canaport tax break
A 2005 municipal deal cut Irving Oil’s Saint John property taxes to a $500,000 cap until 2030, costing the city an estimated $75M over ten years; it was cancelled in 2016.
- Locked The Canaport tax break
In March 2023 Service New Brunswick accidentally charged Irving about $580,000 in Canaport property taxes, calling it an "inadvertent internal computer incident," then reversed the charge and reinstated the exemption.
- Locked The Crown land bargain
In 2022 the province cut softwood pulpwood royalties from $7.59 to $3.40 per cubic metre, below the $3.90 per cubic metre fee it returns to forestry companies, so it now loses money on that wood, effectively giving it away for less than free.
- Locked The Crown land bargain
Roughly half of New Brunswick is public Crown land, and J.D. Irving takes just under half of all the public wood milled into lumber.
- Locked The Crown land bargain
The 2014 provincial forestry strategy raised the Crown softwood cut about 20 percent (660,000 cubic metres a year) by cutting the share of Crown land off-limits to industry to 23 percent from the traditional 30 percent; a UNB forestry professor called it "an abject fail" and he was one of 184 academics who asked the government to halt it.
- Locked The cloned forest
For about 40 years J.D. Irving has run a tree-improvement program that, by its own account, uses selective breeding and vegetative propagation through somatic embryogenesis, primarily of spruce, to produce varietal lines deployed in multi-varietal plantations. The company says its improved seedlings grow 15 to 25 percent faster. The result is a clonal monoculture that narrows the genetic base of the planted Acadian forest.
Caveat This is NOT genetic modification. It is selective breeding and cloning (somatic embryogenesis), sourced to Irving’s own woodlands research page. Framed strictly as clonal monoculture and genetic narrowing.
- Locked The chemical and the messenger
About a third of clearcut public land is sprayed with glyphosate; over the same decades NB’s deer herd fell from roughly 286,000 in the 1980s to about 70,000 by 2014, while Quebec, which banned forest herbicides in 2001, saw its herd grow.
Caveat Balance, kept in: Health Canada maintains glyphosate is not a cancer risk at typical exposure, and the herd link is contested.
- Locked The chemical and the messenger
Rod Cumberland, the province’s deer biologist for 15 years, publicly linked spraying to the herd’s decline; J.D. Irving called his research "irresponsible," and in 2019 he was fired from his teaching post at the Maritime College of Forest Technology.
- Locked How competitors disappear
For decades the Irvings owned every English-language daily newspaper in New Brunswick; a 1981 royal commission recommended breaking up newspaper monopolies and the federal government declined to act.
Penguin Canada Standing Senate Committee on Transport and Communications
- Locked How competitors disappear
A 2006 Senate committee described the concentration of New Brunswick media ownership in one family as something it could not find anywhere else in the developed world.
- Locked How competitors disappear
Inside the Irving newsrooms, reporters were required to file 1,500 words a day and were electronically monitored, as documented in Jacques Poitras’s book.
- Locked How competitors disappear
In 2022 the family sold Brunswick News to Postmedia.
- Locked The rails
The southern New Brunswick freight line is run by NB Southern Railway, held inside J.D. Irving behind the generic holding name "the New Brunswick Railway Company"; Irving incorporated NBSR in 1994 to buy track CP abandoned east of Montreal.
- Locked The rails
NB Southern does not bar Canadian National from the province; the two interchange traffic and cooperate. Irving stepped into the southern line when CP walked away, rather than expelling a rival.
Caveat Correction of a false claim, kept in to preserve credibility.
- Locked The rails
The crude that destroyed Lac-Megantic in 2013 (47 dead) was bound for Irving Oil’s refinery, and the final leg was on Irving’s NB Southern. Irving Oil pleaded guilty to 34 counts of misclassifying the crude’s danger, paid $4M, and gave $75M to the compensation fund; NB Southern was charged with 24 counts and pleaded not guilty.
Caveat MANDATORY: federal prosecutors stated the misclassification did not cause the derailment; the crash’s direct causes lay with the operator (MMA). Irving was the customer that mislabelled the danger and paid. The paperwork did not cause the crash.
- Locked The things we are not allowed to use
On June 27 2003, Irving Shipbuilding took $55 million in federal "economic readjustment" money on the condition that Saint John Shipbuilding, once Canada’s largest shipyard, close permanently. Its 1,150-foot graving dock still stands, unused, beside the gypsum wallboard plant that took the site.
- Locked The refinery and the exits
The Saint John refinery is Canada’s largest at 320,000 barrels a day and New Brunswick’s single largest greenhouse-gas emitter; it runs on imported crude, not Western Canadian.
- Locked The refinery and the exits
Irving Oil launched a strategic review in 2023 that considered a sale, then announced in January 2025 that it is "strong and secure" and will remain a privately held company.
Caveat State as "considered selling, chose not to," never "they’re selling." The review is over; the company stayed private.
- Locked Retail and the unavoidable
Irving’s vertical integration reaches the consumer through service stations, Kent Building Supplies, Cavendish Farms food, and consumer tissue, so it is hard to live in the region without buying from the chain.
Caveat Framed as vertical integration reaching the consumer, NOT a literal monopoly (competitors like Home Depot exist). No market-share figure is claimed for Kent or Irving fuel retail, because none is sourced.
- Locked The human cost and the churn
Bruce Livesey argued that a family dominating the job market can suppress wages because there is no competition bidding workers away; New Brunswick has among the lowest median incomes in Canada with high out-migration.
- Locked The human cost and the churn
In February 2025 Irving Paper laid off about 140 workers, roughly half its Saint John operation, citing uncompetitive electricity rates; a year later the province awarded it up to $45M including an electricity subsidy.
- Testimony The human cost and the churn
Residents of mill towns describe a pattern of large groups of workers laid off and replaced repeatedly, rather than kept on as a stable permanent workforce.
Caveat Presented as firsthand local testimony and a lead to document via the union local (UNIFOR) or EI records, not as a proven published finding. The surrounding casual/on-call structure is documented.
- Locked The premier who actually worked there
Blaine Higgs, premier from 2018 to 2024, was hired by Irving Oil a week after graduating in 1977 and spent 33 years there, rising to senior executive before entering politics.
- Locked The premier who actually worked there
In 2021, emails obtained by CBC showed Premier Higgs personally approved a government letter, signed by a minister but drafted by civil servants, urging the independent Energy and Utilities Board to fast-track an Irving Oil application to raise wholesale fuel margins; Irving later dropped the application for lack of evidence.
- Locked The premier who actually worked there
Opposition attacks on Higgs’s Irving career were often exaggerated; he did not negotiate the Canaport tax break, and in 2016 he supported repealing it.
Caveat Required fairness. The durable conclusion is narrow: a lifelong Irving executive became premier and, in at least one documented case, directed government to act inside an independent regulator on Irving’s behalf.
- Locked The reach
J.D. Irving is the largest landowner in Maine, holding about 1.2 to 1.25 million acres of timberland, and the Irving family ranks among the largest private landowners in the United States. The family’s combined woodland holdings across Maine, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia total roughly 3.2 million acres.
- Locked The reach
The Irvings are tied to the McCain family, New Brunswick’s other great fortune. Harrison and Wallace McCain worked for Irving Oil before co-founding McCain Foods in 1956, and the two families have been entwined ever since, as allies and as rivals.
Caveat The employment link is documented (the McCain brothers worked for Irving Oil); the relationship has been both cooperative and competitive over the decades. No claim is made of a direct intermarriage or that the families act as one.
- Locked The reach
In 2016 Irving Oil and the Arthur L. Irving Family Foundation pledged a combined US$80 million to Dartmouth College, an Ivy League university, to create the Arthur L. Irving Institute for Energy and Society. Students and faculty have since questioned an oil company funding an energy-and-society institute.
- Locked The reach
In 2015 Irving Oil announced a marketing partnership with the Boston Red Sox.
Caveat A marketing tie only. Irving does not own the famous illuminated sign at Fenway Park; that is Citgo’s. Stated narrowly so it cannot be read as more than it was.
Full citations
Every source, with the receipts
- Silas Brown. Irving Paper to get up to $45M in tariff relief funds 1 year after halving production. CBC News, 2026-03-04.
By far the largest share of funding from ONB’s competitive growth fund is going to Irving Paper, about a year after it halved production and laid off 140 staff pointing to "uncompetitive industrial electricity rates."
- Kelsey Adams, Robert Jones. NB Power forced to increase rate subsidies for pulp and paper mills to record $16.6M. CBC News, 2025-04-23.
"N.B. Power’s money doesn’t come out of thin air, it comes out of what people pay on their power bills," said Coon in an interview. "It’s just more pain for consumers."
- Irving Oil not selling after all. CBC News, 2025-01-15.
"We are pleased to confirm Irving Oil will remain a privately held company, and we remain as committed to our people, our customers and our communities today as ever before," it said.
- Jacques Poitras. How the Irvings used a Bermuda tax shelter to carve up their empire. CBC News, 2022-11-07.
"The threat of a massive impending Canadian tax charge in December 2013" was a key driver for carving up the fortune as soon as possible, U.K. lawyer Andrew Hine wrote in a February 2010 court filing in Bermuda.
- Robert Jones. New Brunswick is now charging less than nothing for some of its public timber. CBC News, 2022-09-23.
royalties levied for cutting softwood pulpwood on Crown land have been slashed to levels so low the wood is now effectively being made available for less than free to companies that cut it.
- Irving Oil sentenced, fined $4M on Lac-Megantic-related charges. CBC News, 2017-10-26.
The investigation found that Irving Oil failed to comply with applicable safety requirements by failing to properly classify the crude oil it transported by train, and that the shipping documents on board the trains were [erroneous].
- NB Southern Railway charged in connection with Lac-Megantic. CBC News, 2018-04-06.
- New Brunswick Southern Railway. Wikipedia, 2026.
- Robert Jones. Documents show Higgs was behind controversial letter sent to EUB. CBC News, 2021-03-09.
- Irving Oil drops its application for price hikes as deadline to answer questions approaches. CBC News, 2021-02-08.
- Irving family closing idled Saint John shipyard. CBC News, 2003-06-27.
- Saint John Shipbuilding. Wikipedia, 2026.
- Whit Richardson. Rare interview offers insight into Irving, Maine’s largest landowner. Bangor Daily News, 2014-02-07.
In addition to owning 1.2 million acres of timberland, J.D. Irving Ltd. also operates mills, farms and railway around Maine.
- Irving Family: The Land Report 100. The Land Report, 2017.
- Harrison McCain. Wikipedia, 2026.
Harrison (the 3rd son) and his brother Wallace (the 4th son) worked for oil and gas company Irving Oil.
- Irving family (New Brunswick). Wikipedia, 2026.
- Dartmouth Receives $80 Million for Institute of Energy and Society. Philanthropy News Digest, 2016.
- Students at this Ivy League school call out Irving Oil. Canada’s National Observer, 2023-10-24.
- It’s a Home Run Partnership! Irving Oil announces a partnership with the Boston Red Sox. PR Newswire (Irving Oil), 2015-04-30.
- Robert Jones. Liberals will maintain Crown wood allocations Tories gave to big companies. CBC News, 2018-09-10.
boosted the amount of softwood that industrial forest operations could cut on Crown land annually by 20 per cent, or 660,000 cubic metres, by reducing the amount of Crown land that was off-limits to them ... to 23 per cent from the traditional level of 30 per cent.
Live link news - New Brunswick’s Acadian Forests. CPAWS New Brunswick, 2024.
- Research: Tree Improvement (Woodlands Division). J.D. Irving, Limited (irvingwoodlands.com), 2024.
The company has also integrated vegetative propagation initially through rooted cuttings and then via somatic embryogenesis (SE), primarily of spruces ... to obtain tested varietal lines to be deployed in multi-varietal forestry plantations.
- Robert Jones. ‘Totally plausible’: Forestry profs say faster growing trees likely on Crown plantations. CBC News, 2018-09-21.Live link news
- The herbicide, the deer and the biologist: a New Brunswick spraying fight. CBC News, 2019-12-09.
- Stop Spraying New Brunswick. Stop Spraying New Brunswick, 2026.Live link reference
- Bruce Livesey. Are the Irvings Canada’s biggest corporate welfare bums?. Canada's National Observer, 2017-03-30.
- Bruce Livesey. House of Irving (special report series). Canada's National Observer, 2017.Live link news
- Irving Oil (Canaport tax-break history). Wikipedia, 2026.
- Jacques Poitras. Irving vs. Irving: Canada’s Feuding Billionaires and the Stories They Won’t Tell. Penguin Canada, 2014.Live link book
- Final Report on the Canadian News Media (media concentration in New Brunswick). Standing Senate Committee on Transport and Communications, 2006.Live link government
- #59 The Family That Owns New Brunswick. Canadaland, 2016.Live link podcast
- Monopoly 13: The Irvings. COMMONS (CANADALAND), 2023.Live link podcast
Go deeper
If you want to verify it yourself
The investigations this work stands on. Read them. They are more detailed than anything here, and they are the reason any of it can be said at all.